Sky Train Case: Lawyer Withdraws Over Fair Trial Concerns

Solomon Asamoah

 

Things took an unexpected turn yesterday in the Sky Train trial as Victoria Barth, lawyer for former Chief Executive Officer of the Ghana Infrastructure Investment Fund (GIIF), Solomon Asamoah, withdrew her services over issues likely to infringe on her client’s right to a fair trial.

Mr. Asamoah and former Board Chairman of the Fund, Prof. Christopher Ameyaw-Akumfi are standing trial for allegedly causing a $2 million financial loss to the state by investing it in the Sky Train project.

Mrs. Barth withdrew her legal representation in protest against the court’s October 29 directive requiring her client to open his defence and testify before he could call his subpoenaned witnesses, arguing that proceeding under the circumstances could undermine his constitutional right to a fair trial.

She announced what she described as a painful decision in court after the trial judge insisted that proceedings continue with Mr. Asamoah taking the witness stand, despite applications pending before the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court challenging earlier orders of the High Court.

Explaining her decision, she said she could not participate in proceedings that, in her view, were inconsistent with her client’s constitutional right to remain silent and not be compelled to give evidence in a manner that could prejudice his defence.

“My Lady, respectfully, the court gives me no choice but to withdraw my representation for A1 (Mr. Asamoah) at this stage,” she told the court.

Mrs. Barth had earlier informed the court that she had filed an application for certiorari at the Supreme Court to quash the judge’s directive on the accused persons to first mount the witness box before they could call their witnesses.

She also told the court that she has filed a repeat application for stay of proceedings at the Court of Appeal pending the determination of the appeal against the directive.

A third application is seeking to restrain the High Court from taking evidence from Mr. Asamoah before hearing the witnesses subpoenaed by him, pending the determination of the applications before the Supreme Court.

She said the applications had been scheduled for November 23, and therefore prayed the court to adjourn the matter to await the decision of the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal.

Mrs. Barth added that she could not be a willing party to proceedings that could undermine the applications she had filed before the two superior courts.

Opposition

That prayer was opposed by Deputy Attorney General, Dr. Justice Srem-Sai, who described it as an abuse of court processes intended to frustrate the trial and prevent Mr. Asamoah from entering the witness box.

He said multiple applications filed before different courts were designed to achieve one objective: preventing Mr. Asamoah from testifying.

Dr. Srem-Sai further maintained that there was no order restraining the High Court from proceeding with the trial, adding that an earlier application for a stay of proceedings had already been argued and dismissed by the trial court.

The trial judge, Justice Audrey Kocuvie-Tay, however, ruled that the court had not received formal notice of the applications counsel said were pending before the superior courts.

She further held that the mere filing of such applications did not automatically restrain the High Court from continuing with the trial, adding that the court will proceed to take the evidence of Mr. Asamoah.

Withdrawal

It was at this point that Mrs. Barth announced her withdrawal, stressing that her decision arose from her inability to comply with a directive she believed could compromise her client’s constitutional rights.

Dr. Srem-Sai, relying on Rule 85 of the Legal Profession (Professional Conduct and Etiquette) Rules 2020, described the stated grounds for withdrawal as problematic, suggesting that counsel appeared to regard the refusal of her applications as sufficient justification for abandoning the defence.

“Our position is that the withdrawal is defective and ought to be disregarded and treated as a ploy to achieve through the back door the predetermined purpose of not allowing A1 to testify,” he argued.

In response, Mrs. Barth maintained that Rule 85 was not absolute, pointing to the provision that a lawyer could withdraw from representing a client for good cause.

She insisted that she had explained the circumstances compelling her decision and maintained that she was not withdrawing out of personal preference.

Justice Kocuvie-Tay, consequently, adjourned the trial to November 23, 2026, to allow Mr. Asamoah to engage another lawyer.

BY Gibril Abdul Razak