Galamsey: Does Ghana have a gold problem, or a political leadership suffering from a common sense deficit?

COMMON SENSE, WHERE ART THOU?
There are times when one genuinely struggles to understand how a country blessed with so many natural resources, educated professionals, technical expertise and economic opportunities can remain trapped in problems that should not require rocket science to solve. Ghana’s galamsey crisis is one such embarrassment.
For decades, we have listened to politicians from both the NPP and NDC pontificate about illegal mining. We have witnessed presidential addresses, ministerial pronouncements, parliamentary debates, military deployments, task forces, committees, arrests and countless declarations of war against galamsey. Yet, our rivers continue to suffer, our forests continue to disappear and the illegal mining industry continues to find oxygen.
The NPP blames the NDC. The NDC blames the NPP. Politicians who once occupied the corridors of power suddenly acquire extraordinary environmental consciousness when they move into opposition. Those who inherit government discover that the problem is considerably more complicated than they previously suggested. The political theatre continues, while Ghana’s natural inheritance is being sacrificed.
At this point, perhaps we should stop asking whether Ghana has enough policies to fight galamsey and start asking a more embarrassing question: Does our political leadership possess the basic common sense required to understand and solve the problem? Because, frankly, some of the approaches we have witnessed over the years raise serious questions about the quality of thinking that goes into national policymaking.
How can a country spend decades discussing a problem without adequately connecting its economic causes, educational consequences, industrial opportunities and environmental implications? How can successive governments continue approaching the same problem with variations of the same unsuccessful interventions and expect a different outcome? And how can politicians who have had access to the Presidency, Parliament, ministries, security agencies, technical advisers and enormous public resources continue behaving as though the solution is beyond the intellectual capacity of the Ghanaian state?
Perhaps the problem is not a shortage of intelligence among ordinary Ghanaians. Perhaps it is the extraordinary shortage of common sense in the political decision-making process.
THE ABSURDITY OF CHASING THE LABOURER WHILE IGNORING THE ECONOMIC MACHINERY
Let us begin with something so obvious that one would expect it to be the starting point of every serious government intervention. Galamsey is an economic enterprise. It has financiers, equipment owners, suppliers, operators, buyers, logistics providers and commercial networks.
Who finances these operations? Who purchases the excavators? Who supplies the fuel? Who purchases the gold? Who facilitates the movement of the machinery and the proceeds? These are basic investigative questions, not intellectual puzzles requiring a PhD in astrophysics.
Yet, too often, the public sees a disproportionate focus on the young men at the bottom of the operation, while the networks that finance and commercialise illegal mining remain insufficiently exposed.
Why should identifying the man holding a shovel be easier than identifying the person financing the operation? Why should the excavator operator become the convenient face of galamsey while the person who owns the equipment escapes scrutiny? Why should the person digging in a river be easier to prosecute than the person purchasing the gold?
If the state cannot systematically trace the money, machinery, gold buyers and commercial beneficiaries, then what exactly are our intelligence, security and regulatory institutions doing?
A government that genuinely intends to dismantle galamsey must follow the money, investigate the commercial networks and prosecute those responsible, irrespective of their political connections. Destroying an excavator without dismantling the financial network capable of purchasing another one is not a strategy. It is an expensive demonstration of activity without necessarily achieving lasting results.
And if our politicians cannot understand that distinction, perhaps they should spend less time addressing the nation and more time understanding the economics of the industry they claim to be fighting.
THE MOST OBVIOUS SOLUTION: MAKE LEGITIMATE EMPLOYMENT MORE ATTRACTIVE THAN GALAMSEY
Here is where ordinary common sense should become the foundation of national policy. People need livelihoods. A young person without employment, a dependable income or realistic economic prospects will naturally be attracted to available opportunities, however dangerous or unlawful they may be.
You cannot repeatedly tell unemployed young people to abandon galamsey while offering them nothing credible to replace the income they derive from it. That is not environmental policy. It is wishful thinking dressed up as governance.
Ghana is a major cocoa-producing country. Why have successive governments not pursued a much more ambitious programme of attracting large-scale cocoa processing companies into strategic cocoa-producing communities? Modern processing facilities operating multiple production shifts would require engineers, technicians, machine operators, laboratory personnel, packaging workers, logistics operators, warehouse staff and administrators. The employment opportunities would extend beyond the factories to farmers, transport operators, food vendors, artisans and small businesses.
What about timber? Why should we continue extracting natural resources without developing the manufacturing capacity to produce furniture, school desks, hospital beds, office furniture, doors, wardrobes and other finished products on a much larger scale? Why must we continue exporting economic opportunities along with our raw materials?
But cocoa and timber are only the beginning.
Consider cashew processing. Ghana could attract investors to establish factories producing kernels, cashew butter, cashew milk and other value-added products.
Consider palm oil and palm kernel processing, with opportunities in edible oils, soap, cosmetics and industrial derivatives.
Consider cassava and starch manufacturing, including industrial starch, flour, glucose and animal feed.
Consider modern rice milling, packaging and storage facilities.
Consider fruit and vegetable processing. Pineapples, mangoes, oranges and tomatoes could support industries producing juices, concentrates, canned products and other processed foods.
Consider fisheries and aquaculture, including fish farming, fish processing, cold storage, packaging and fish feed production.
Consider livestock and poultry processing, including meat processing, animal feed and leather manufacturing.
Consider construction materials manufacturing, including ceramic tiles, bricks, roofing materials and prefabricated building components.
Consider recycling and waste management, including plastic recycling, paper processing and metal recovery.
Consider renewable energy component assembly, solar equipment and battery systems.
Consider pharmaceutical and medical supplies manufacturing, as well as tourism, hospitality and eco-tourism in rural communities.
These are not imaginary industries. They are identifiable economic activities with established markets and potential for domestic and international investment, subject to proper feasibility studies and commercial discipline.
Now, here is the question that should embarrass every government that has occupied office in Ghana. Why have we been unable to organise these opportunities into a deliberate national industrial employment strategy capable of absorbing a meaningful proportion of our unemployed youth?
Is the country incapable of identifying suitable locations? Do we lack universities, engineers, economists, investment advisers and development planners? Are there no international companies looking for investment opportunities? Or have we simply become so accustomed to political declarations that we have forgotten the difference between announcing an economic programme and actually implementing one?
The tragedy is that we have spent years debating how to stop young people from engaging in illegal mining without demonstrating comparable determination to create productive economic alternatives for them. That is an extraordinary failure of common sense.
AND THEN WE HAVE AN EDUCATION SYSTEM THAT SOMETIMES CLOSES THE VERY DOORS WE EXPECT YOUNG PEOPLE TO WALK THROUGH
Perhaps the greatest irony of our national development predicament is that our education and employment policies are not sufficiently integrated.
Parents make enormous sacrifices to educate their children. Some sell property, borrow money and exhaust their savings because they believe education will provide their children with opportunities.
Then comes WASSCE.
A student may perform well in several subjects, demonstrate considerable aptitude in a particular discipline and have a clear career ambition. Yet failure in English Language or Mathematics can become a significant obstacle to tertiary admission, depending on the programme and institution.
Let me make something clear. English and Mathematics are important foundational subjects. Nobody is suggesting that we should abandon academic standards. But does common sense not suggest that university admission requirements should also reflect the competencies relevant to the particular programme a student wishes to pursue?
Why should a student with demonstrable aptitude in creative arts, humanities or another discipline have their future unnecessarily constrained by an inflexible admission framework? Why can we not introduce programme-specific admission pathways, supported by bridging and remedial courses where foundational competencies need strengthening?
A student pursuing engineering must demonstrate the necessary mathematical ability. Someone pursuing medicine must satisfy the relevant science requirements. A student pursuing journalism, the creative arts or other disciplines should be assessed with appropriate consideration of the competencies required for those fields.
This is not lowering standards. It is applying intelligence to education policy.
And what happens to the young person who cannot afford another examination attempt, cannot secure admission and has no realistic employment alternative? We cannot assume that every student who drops out will end up in illegal mining. But we must recognise that educational exclusion, unemployment and economic deprivation can increase the vulnerability of young people to dangerous informal activities.
The same political leadership that has failed to sufficiently expand educational and economic opportunities then turns around to condemn some of these young people for seeking livelihoods in illegal mining. What kind of development thinking is that?
We cannot build an education system that closes doors, an economy that fails to open new ones, and then deploy the military to deal with the young people standing outside. If that contradiction does not expose a serious common-sense deficit in our national planning, what does?
THE NPP AND NDC: TWO PARTIES, ONE RECURRENT FAILURE
Now let us address the political elephant in the room. Both the NPP and NDC must take responsibility for the national conversation surrounding galamsey. Neither party can claim exclusive ownership of the problem, and neither should be permitted to escape accountability by pointing to the failures of its predecessor.
The NPP has governed. The NDC has governed. Both have had opportunities to demonstrate that they understand the relationship between environmental protection, employment creation, industrialisation and education. Yet, the country continues to witness the familiar spectacle of one party accusing the other, while the underlying problems persist.
It is almost as though our politicians have perfected the art of identifying problems only when somebody else is responsible for solving them. When in opposition, they become environmental scientists, industrialisation experts, employment specialists and education reformers. Once in government, many of those brilliant observations mysteriously disappear.
The NPP seems to believe that exposing the failures of the NDC constitutes a development strategy. The NDC sometimes behaves as though inheriting the failures of the NPP automatically absolves it of the responsibility to produce better outcomes. What a remarkable way to run a country!
Ghanaians did not elect the NPP and NDC to become permanent debating societies. They elected them to solve problems.
What is the point of having a Parliament if our legislators cannot develop a durable national framework for protecting the country’s natural resources? What is the point of having ministries, departments and agencies if every change of government must bring another round of policy experimentation? What is the point of spending millions of cedis on consultants, workshops, committees and conferences if the outcome is another policy document that eventually gathers dust?
And what is the point of having politicians who spend enormous energy fighting for power but appear unable to demonstrate the same energy in applying basic economic reasoning to national problems?
Perhaps both parties should pause their endless political warfare and ask themselves whether the country is being governed or merely managed through a succession of press conferences.
COMMON SENSE IS NOT A LUXURY. IT IS A REQUIREMENT OF LEADERSHIP.
Let us simplify the entire galamsey debate.
If people are attracted to illegal mining because it offers income, create legitimate employment that can compete with that income.
If illegal mining is financed by identifiable commercial networks, investigate the financiers and dismantle those networks.
If degraded lands and polluted rivers require restoration, turn environmental rehabilitation into organised employment.
If our natural resources are being exported without sufficient domestic value addition, attract manufacturing investment and develop local industrial capacity.
If our education system unnecessarily restricts some capable students, review the admission framework and introduce appropriate alternative pathways without compromising essential standards.
If enforcement is necessary, enforce the law consistently, without regard to political affiliation, wealth or influence.
What exactly is so intellectually demanding about this integrated approach?
Of course, implementation requires capital, infrastructure, technical expertise, credible feasibility studies, institutional coordination and time. Not every industry can be established overnight, and not every unemployed young person can immediately be absorbed into manufacturing. But that is precisely why we have governments. They are supposed to plan, prioritise, mobilise investment and execute.
We cannot continue treating the existence of implementation challenges as an excuse for the absence of imagination.
The real test of leadership is not how eloquently a politician describes a problem. It is whether that politician can organise available resources and institutions to produce measurable results.
GHANA DESERVES LEADERSHIP, NOT AN ENDLESS PARADE OF POLITICAL EXCUSES.
I find it particularly disturbing that we have allowed galamsey to become a permanent national conversation, almost as though the destruction of our rivers and forests is an unavoidable feature of Ghanaian life. It is not.
Our rivers do not belong to the NPP or NDC. Our forests are not the private property of politicians, financiers or traditional authorities. Our mineral resources are not the inheritance of a privileged few. They belong to Ghana, including generations yet unborn.
The political class must understand that the country cannot continue paying for its failure to plan. Every polluted river, destroyed forest, unemployed young person and wasted educational opportunity represents a cost to the national future.
And perhaps the greatest humiliation is that we have the resources, the professionals, the institutions and the economic opportunities to do considerably better. Yet, we continue behaving as though the solution to every national problem is another committee, another task force, another presidential directive or another round of political accusations.
At some point, Ghanaians must ask whether the people competing so aggressively to govern this country understand what governing actually entails.
Because if, after decades of political competition, enormous public expenditure and repeated changes of administration, our leaders still cannot connect education, industrialisation, employment and environmental protection into a coherent national strategy, then the problem is no longer simply galamsey. It is a crisis of political thinking.
Perhaps Ghana’s greatest national resource is not the gold beneath our soil, but the common sense that should guide how we manage it. Unfortunately, judging by the repeated failures of successive administrations, that particular resource appears to be in dangerously short supply.
The NPP and NDC should stop insulting Ghanaians with their endless blame games. The country needs fewer political speeches and considerably more evidence of intelligent governance.
A country cannot be permanently governed by people who mistake political survival for national development, activity for achievement and endless talk for leadership.
Ghana deserves better. Much better.
K. A. Asirifi
COMMON SENSE, WHERE ART THOU?
By Kwame Addo Asirifi
Tags: